Skip to content
Indianapolis Coin BuyerCoins, gold and silver

Coin and gold buyer in Central Indiana

Sell coins, gold and silver in Indianapolis

Buffalo nickels from a Hendricks County farmhouse, Franklin halves from a grandfather's dresser, silver certificates in a family Bible or gold rings in a jewelry box. Every piece gets a price on paper.

  • Free appraisal at a private time
  • Testing and weighing done while you watch
  • Same-day payment by cash or wire
Album of old American coins
Gold $3,864.26Silver $47.53per troy ounce, today

Ask for a free appraisal

We return every call the same day and set a private time.

Add a description (optional)

01 / Who we are

A plain way to sell in Indy

Hoosiers tend to hang on to things. Coin folders started in the 1950s, rolls of silver halves saved in 1964, gold coins bought in the 1970s and a sock drawer of old bills can all sit untouched for decades. When the time comes to sell, people want to know they are getting a fair number.

We give you every number. Each coin, ring and bar gets tested, weighed and listed with its metal, purity or grade and our price. Gold and silver are priced on the live market, which you can watch on our screen. You decide what to sell, if anything.

03 / Process

How it works

  1. Get in touch

    Call or send the form with a line about what you have. We call back today to pick a time.

  2. See every test

    Gold and silver are tested and weighed in front of you. Coins and bills are checked under magnification.

  3. Make your call

    Sell all of it, part of it or none. The written list is yours to keep.

04 / Local

The Crossroads of America

Indianapolis was picked as Indiana's capital in 1820, when the site was still forest along the White River. Alexander Ralston, who had helped survey Washington, laid out the Mile Square with a circle at its center. Railroads arrived in the 1840s and 1850s, the country's first union station opened here in 1853, and the city earned its nickname as the Crossroads of America.

Those rail lines carried farm money, factory paychecks and later racing money through the city. Central Indiana families saved coins and silver from all of it, and their collections still fill safes from Broad Ripple to Beech Grove.

1913 to 1938

Buffalo nickel values

Why dates wear off, which ones matter and what dateless coins bring.

Read the guide →
1948 to 1963

Franklin half values

Every Franklin is silver. Full bell lines bring the premiums.

Read the guide →
Blue seals

Silver certificate values

Which old bills sell for face and which bring more.

Read the guide →

05 / Coverage

Carmel to Greenwood, Avon to Fishers

We work with sellers in Marion, Hamilton, Hendricks and Johnson counties.

FAQ

Frequently asked

Where can I sell coins in Indianapolis?

Indianapolis Coin Buyer buys old coins, paper money, gold, silver and bullion by private appointment, Monday to Saturday. Call 317-406-0486 or send the form to book.

Do you buy old paper money?

Yes. Silver certificates, gold certificates, national bank notes and large-size notes are all welcome.

Is the appraisal free?

Yes. There is never a fee, and you are under no obligation.

Do I have to sell everything?

No. Sell the pieces you choose and keep the rest.

How do you pay?

Smaller amounts come in cash at the table, and bigger ones by wire before the banks close.

Learn what your coins and gold are worth

Book a free appraisal anywhere in Central Indiana. Each piece is tested and weighed while you watch, and every price goes on paper.

Call (317) 406-0486Request an offer